SAN FRANCISCO, October 13 — AI shopping assistants recommend national chains over small and independent retailers between 90 and 94 percent of the time, according to a Vaer AI study of roughly 460,000 responses commissioned by Lightspeed Commerce and released September 29. The scale of the imbalance, drawn from more than 20,000 prompts across ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews in ten product categories and four cities (Los Angeles, San Francisco, New York and Montreal), reframes what the shift to AI-mediated commerce actually means for the long tail of retail.
The bias is structural, not incidental. With live web search disabled, the systems named a national chain 63 to 70 percent of the time and surfaced a small or local shop in only about one in ten top recommendations. Turning web search on softened the pattern but didn’t invert it: large chains still took 46 to 58 percent of top slots. Google AI Overviews recommended no local store at all in 68 percent of shopping responses. Specificity made things worse, not better. For branded product searches, independent shops fell from roughly a third of top recommendations down to that same one-in-ten floor.
Then comes the prompt-engineering twist. Adding the word “independent” cut large-chain recommendations from about 44 percent to as little as 9 percent, and more than doubled small-business mentions. “Local” and “near me” didn’t produce the same effect, because the models treat a nearby chain branch as satisfying the query.
A narrower October UBS analysis across twelve prompts in three states, covering ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Muse, reached a similar verdict: Walmart and Costco surfaced constantly. Fit Small Business, which reported the UBS data, noted its scope was considerably narrower than the Lightspeed work.
The implication is uncomfortable for anyone still treating AI retrieval as neutral. AI has already overtaken social media as a local-business discovery channel, and AI search converts at roughly triple the rate of organic. A channel that funnels nine of ten consumers to incumbents, by default, isn’t a discovery layer. It’s a distribution moat.
Sources
- AI Favors Big Retailers Over Local Stores 9 Out of 10 Times, New Study Finds
- When you ask AI where to shop, it sends you to the big guys
- Lightspeed Commerce CEO: our study analyzed half a million AI shopping responses
- AI shopping answers keep sending customers to the big chains, study finds
- AI Shopping Cites Small Stores but Recommends Big Chains, Studies Find