TULSA, Okla., Oct. 14 — Across 100 U.S. small businesses, 10 industries, and 11 metro areas, AI assistants ghosted 80 of them when asked to recommend a provider to a plausible buyer. That’s the headline from Modern Asset Lab’s Match Protocol benchmark, released Tuesday by the Tulsa consultancy founded by Clint Rogers, who also runs Techstars-backed Creativo AI.
The method is more useful than the slogan. Each business was tested through an average of 27.8 simulated buyer conversations, up to 32 per business, scored across five weighted stages. Being Recommended carries 35 percent of the score, more than any other layer. The composite average landed at 50.9 out of 100.
Here’s what makes the finding sting. The same businesses averaged 80 on Found and 88 on Trusted, but just 18 on Recommended. The engines could see them. They could even vouch for them. They wouldn’t suggest them. Of the 100, 31 were never named at all, 36 were never recommended, and 62 were recommended three times or fewer. Only 8 crossed the half-mark.
Industry patterns were uneven. Plumbing led at 56.6 and HVAC at 54.9, while dental practices scored under 60 in 10 of 11 cases, roofing in 9 of 11, and auto repair in 9 of 10. Modern Asset Lab calls its tiers Ghosted, Friend Zone, First Date, Going Steady, and The One; 80 businesses sat in Ghosted, two in Going Steady, none in The One.
The sample is directional, not nationally representative. But Semrush’s 2026 AI Visibility Index, built on 25 million U.S. and 2.5 million U.K. prompts across 22 categories from January through July, points the same direction: fewer than half of the top 100 mentioned brands also ranked in the top 100 cited domains every month in both markets. AI-referred visitors convert 60 percent better and generate 53 percent more revenue per visit. MarTech’s Constantine von Hoffman noted that Chevrolet, Disney, Ford, Honda, Marvel, Nintendo and Toyota sat outside the top 500 for citations every month measured. Tesco ranked 25th among ChatGPT’s most-cited U.K. domains in July. Asda ranked 606th.
Legibility isn’t endorsement. The engines decide who gets mentioned, and most small businesses aren’t in the conversation.
Sources
- https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/modern-asset-lab-launches-match-protocol-after-benchmark-finds-ai-ghosts-8-in-10-small-businesses-302908265.html
- https://martech.org/your-ai-visibility-score-may-be-hiding-a-problem/
- https://finance.yahoo.com/technology/ai/articles/semrush-releases-2026-ai-visibility-090100520.html
- https://www.semrush.com/news/474244-semrush-releases-2026-ai-visibility-index-revealing-its-first-uk-benchmark/
- https://agilebrandguide.com/yesterdays-martech-ai-cx-news-october-15-2026/